no one (should be) doubting the work put in by people to make #ipug the success that has been, but before newnet even #ipug was in decline, activity grew steadily for months as soon as the first beta was used in pugs, even before then people were excited about newnet
The euro iCTF scene suffered from terrible admining, plus clanbase offered very little flexibility in how the season could be managed and formatted
cups and leagues hosted outside of CB were smaller and more specialised, they didn't have the means to grow into anything bigger
there was no growth anywhere, only attrition
making it a global scene straight away and sucessfully putting a pug channel or linked pug onto quakenet would have brought in players from italy, poland, russia, isreal, estonia, hungary and a lot more players from the uk, nl, belgium, pt, spain and germany than the scene actually ended up with
i know there was some effort put into making this GG channel more visible through advertisment on QN, at this point the chance to bring in these players is probably long lost
still, it was the admin's desicion to do this and it's clear they thought it was the right thing to do
TL;DR just don't make this community suffer from the same inflexibility that cb did