by Shotman » Wed Apr 30, 2014 10:47 pm
For those who don't know I am Shotman a retired UT99 player that used to be very active at the beginning of #ipug/global unreal but went to inactive after I had a 24 hour job. Nowadays I have some free time and I use that time to play Unreal and Thief (2014). Some people from uK brought this topic to my attention.
Anyways, I just want to put my input into this conversation. I know most of you guys want to revive UT99 into the scene and show many people of what is worth. Now TimTim, since your trying to "replicate" UT99 on the unreal engine 4, why not try to make another Unreal with a proper storyline and if that becomes successful than make it to an "replicate" of Unreal Tournament. I say this because the one thing that UT99 became so popular was because of Unreal 1 and Return to the Nali Pa with its nice scenery, weapons, music and storyline. Therefore, I believe a lot of people would want to have a good storyline or freedom when player wants to play a campaign and such. So if you could make a new Unreal, call it a different name so you won't be sued, where it would get picked up from Unreal 1. Where the main person landed on another planet covered with Skaarj and are using Nali as slaves.
Then, you would need to focus of the new players or the new generation. For this to happen, you need to look at the public scene not the pug scene. You would have a higher chance of brining the public scene over to the pug scene. Also TimTim focusing on a one weapon game (IG), is a horrible idea that would just kill a game. You would just bring in the old public from #ipug and it would not help it grow. Weapons is the way to go, not IG.
I would like to add and ask you think FPS games these days suck? For me, I would simply answer that they are pretty much the same thing and use the same movements. None of the games stand out and become very boring. The two examples, which are probably the obvious, is COD4 and Modern Warfare. These two games are exactly the same thing and the only way for a new UT is if it would stand out.
Now the UT3 vs UT99 debate. They are both great games, believe it or not, and UT3 had a lot of potential for being great. If you remember UT3 was really popular and had a lot of people talking because it had a lot of the old mechanics with new mechanics. However the only thing that people forgot about UT3 was Gears of War. Epic pretty much dug the grave of UT3 because they wanted to revive another of their classic games. For those people that are saying that UT3 sucks, if it wasn't for Gears of War, then you would probably be playing UT3 now and they would have been more of UTs. Hell UT3 storyline was good and left you hanging so there has to be a new UT4 in the future.
I agree with Morpheous that UT99 is dead and with Gamespy closing down it might make it worse for the community.
If it doesn't make sense than too bad because I was in hurry and wanted to put my input in this convo.